Comparisons
A Tribute video or a printed photo book?

A group video and a group book answer the same wish: everyone says something, and the person gets it all at once. Tribute is one of the services that makes the video. Friends and family each record a short message, and Tribute turns them into one film. A printed photo book does the same job on paper. Neither is better in general. They suit different people, and the choice is mostly about the person you're making it for.
The short answer: if voices, laughter and seeing faces move matter most, and they'll happily watch it on a screen, a Tribute video is the better gift. If they'd rather have something to hold and look through again, with no screen at all, a printed book is.
How Tribute works
Guests record on any device, with "no app, no login", and Tribute sends the invites and the reminders (Tribute homepage, checked 17 Nov 2026). Its homepage says the most successful Tributes invite an average of 30 people through its automated email reminders. There's also Tribute for Work, aimed at HR teams.
You choose a plan before you start collecting, and payment comes first. Do-it-yourself videos cost $35, $49 or $99 depending on length. Concierge, where Tribute does the editing, is $99, and Concierge with a Video Book is $149 (Tribute pricing page, checked 17 Nov 2026).
The Video Book costs $99: a linen hardback with a 7 inch screen inside that plays the video. Tribute doesn't make a printed photo book (Tribute help centre, delivery options, checked 17 Nov 2026).
How a Paper Chain book works
Paper Chain is a printed photo book made by a group. You start it in a minute, then share one link or add people by email so each gets their own link. Contributors open it on their phone, type their name, choose photos and write a line under each, with no app, account or password. People added by email get reminders 3 days before the due date, the day before and on the day, and they stop once that person adds something.
Each photo gets a 21 x 28 cm page of its own with the caption in large type, and a note without a photo gets a page too. You see every page, change the order, leave things out and fix captions, then order. You pay nothing until then. The book is printed in or near the country it's going to and posted to the door.
Side by side
| What you're comparing | Tribute video | Paper Chain book |
|---|---|---|
| What they get | An edited video montage, or a Video Book with a 7 inch screen | A printed photo book, 21 x 28 cm, softcover or hardcover |
| What people send | Video messages recorded on any device | Photos with a caption each, and notes |
| Accounts for contributors | None: no app, no login | None: no app, no account |
| Reminders | Tribute sends invites and reminders | 3 days before the due date, the day before and on the day, for people added by email |
| When you pay | Before collecting | Only when you order the book |
| Price | Do-it-yourself $35 to $99; Video Book $99; Concierge with Video Book $149 | Shown up front, printing and delivery included |
| To enjoy it | A screen with sound, or the Video Book's own screen | Open the book; no screen, sound or charging |
| Voices and movement | Yes | No; photos and words only |
Tribute details in the table are from its homepage, pricing page and help centre, checked 17 Nov 2026.
When a video is the better choice
- Voices matter. Hearing a grandchild say happy birthday, or an old friend laughing halfway through a story, is something paper can't do.
- Contributors would rather talk than write. Some people freeze at a blank caption box but can talk to a phone for a minute.
- It's for the party. A video plays on a big screen in front of everyone, which a book can't.
- You have no time to edit. Concierge hands the editing to Tribute.
- The person lives on their phone. For someone who watches everything on a screen anyway, a video fits how they already spend their evenings.
When a printed book is the better choice
- They don't want another screen. A book needs no charging, no volume and no remembering how to press play.
- They'll go back to it. A book can sit on the coffee table and be picked up for five minutes at a time, and handed to visitors.
- Older eyes. One photo to a page and captions in type up to 18 point are easy to read without glasses hunting. More on that in our large-print photo book page.
- Camera-shy contributors. Plenty of people who'd never record a video will happily send a photo and a line.
- You'd rather not pay up front. It's free to start, and you only pay when you order.
Doing both
If you can't choose, some families do both: a video for the party and a book for afterwards. If you do, ask once. Put both requests in the same message, so nobody gets chased twice, and tell people a short video and a couple of photos are plenty. Our guide to getting family to send photos has wording that works, and the retirement photo book page shows how one comes together for a leaving do.
Here's what a Paper Chain book costs in the US today, delivery included:
| Pages | Softcover | Hardcover | Holds up to |
|---|---|---|---|
| 28 pages | US$30 | US$37 | 26 photos |
| 40 pages | US$32 | US$40 | 38 photos |
| 60 pages | US$38 | US$47 | 58 photos |
| 80 pages | US$44 | US$54 | 78 photos |
| 100 pages | US$50 | US$62 | 98 photos |
| 120 pages | US$56 | US$69 | 118 photos |
| 150 pages | US$65 | US$80 | 148 photos |
| 200 pages | US$80 | US$98 | 198 photos |
Paper Chain isn't connected with Tribute; details about Tribute are from its own website, checked on 17 November 2026, and may have changed.