Comparisons
A group leaving card or a leaving book?

When someone leaves, someone else ends up with the card. These days that usually means an online group card: a link goes round, everyone types a message, and the card is printed and posted, or sent as a link. The other option is a leaving book, a printed book with a page from each person. Both are good. Which one fits depends on who's leaving, how long they've been there and how many people want to say something.
The short answer: for a colleague who's been with you a year or two, a big team signing one line each, or a tight budget, a group card is the right call. For someone leaving after years, retiring, or moving away, where people have photos and more to say, a leaving book is worth the extra.
How a group card works, with Moonpig as the example
Moonpig's group cards promise "Many Messages, One Card". You share a link, people add their messages, you review them, and Moonpig prints the card and sends it straight to the person. A card takes up to 50 messages, you can set an optional deadline, and there are no photo pages (Moonpig help centre, checked 17 Nov 2026). We couldn't find a published price for group cards, so check on Moonpig's site before you start.
Other UK services work in a similar way. Thankbox is digital and costs £4.99 or £8.99 including VAT, and you can pay for it from the money you collect (Thankbox pricing page, checked 17 Nov 2026). GroupGreeting is £5.29 a card, takes any number of signers and sends a PDF rather than a printed card (GroupGreeting pricing page, checked 17 Nov 2026). For something printed, Givetastic turns its e-card into a booklet of up to 32 pages for £6.99, including Royal Mail 1st Class (Givetastic, checked 17 Nov 2026), and GroupLeavingCards prints a booklet of up to 30 pages for £4.99 plus £2.99 postage, which it says is a temporary price, normally £9.99 (GroupLeavingCards print page, checked 17 Nov 2026).
How a leaving book works
A Paper Chain leaving book starts the same way: you set it up in a minute and share one link in the team chat, or add people's names and emails so each gets their own link and reminders before the due date. Nobody needs an app or an account. Each person types their name, picks photos from their phone and writes a line under each, or just writes a note.
Then it becomes a book. Each photo gets its own 21 x 28 cm page with the caption in large type, and each note gets a page to itself, so the message from the person who sat next to them for nine years isn't squeezed into a corner. You see every page, take out the photo from the Christmas do that nobody needs to see again, fix spelling and order. The last page says "With love" with everyone's names, and the book is posted to the door. There's more on a leaving book for a colleague.
Side by side
| What you're comparing | Group card (Moonpig as the example) | Paper Chain leaving book |
|---|---|---|
| What they get | A printed card from Moonpig; a digital card or PDF from some others | A printed photo book, 21 x 28 cm, softcover or hardcover |
| How many messages | Up to 50 on a Moonpig group card | Everyone you collect, from 28 to 200 pages |
| Photos | No photo pages on a Moonpig group card | One photo to a page, caption underneath |
| How people join | A shared link | A shared link, or a personal link by email; no app or account |
| Deadline and reminders | Optional deadline on Moonpig | A due date, with reminders for people added by email |
| Price | Digital cards £4.99 to £8.99 (Thankbox); printed booklets from £4.99 plus postage (GroupLeavingCards) | Shown up front, printing and delivery included |
| Best for | A quick, low-cost card from a big group | Someone leaving after years, retiring or moving away |
Card details in the table are from Moonpig's help centre and the Thankbox and GroupLeavingCards pricing pages, checked 17 Nov 2026.
When a group card is the right call
- They haven't been there long. A card from the team is the normal, proportionate thing.
- Most people will write one line. Fifty one-liners fit on a card, and a book of one-liners with no photos would feel thin.
- The budget is small. Group cards cost a few pounds, and nobody has to chip in much.
- You need it today. A digital card can go out the moment it's ready.
- You're collecting money too. Thankbox lets you pay for the card from the collection.
- Everyone knows how it works. Moonpig is a name people recognise, so nobody needs the link explained.
When a leaving book is worth it
- They've been there years. Long service, or a retirement, deserves more than a card that goes in a drawer. See the retirement photo book for that version.
- There are photos. Away days, the office dog, the leaving drinks for people who left before them. A book puts them on pages big enough to see.
- More than 50 people want to sign. A book has room for everyone, whether they send a photo or just a note.
- People have more to say. A note gets a page of its own, not a corner.
- They're moving abroad. The book is printed in or near the country it's going to and posted to their new door.
Running either one well
- One person owns it. Two organisers means two links and half the messages in each.
- Set the due date a few days before you need it, not the day of the leaving do.
- Ask for something specific: "a photo from a work trip and one line" gets more replies than "write something nice".
- Keep the collection separate from the card, and never post who has and hasn't paid. There's more in how to organise a group gift at work.
- If people are stuck for words, send them leaving card messages to borrow from.
Here's what a Paper Chain book costs in the UK today, delivery included:
| Pages | Softcover | Hardcover | Holds up to |
|---|---|---|---|
| 28 pages | £21 | £26 | 26 photos |
| 40 pages | £22 | £28 | 38 photos |
| 60 pages | £27 | £33 | 58 photos |
| 80 pages | £31 | £39 | 78 photos |
| 100 pages | £36 | £44 | 98 photos |
| 120 pages | £40 | £49 | 118 photos |
| 150 pages | £47 | £58 | 148 photos |
| 200 pages | £58 | £71 | 198 photos |
Paper Chain isn't connected with Moonpig; details about Moonpig are from its own website, checked on 17 November 2026, and may have changed. The same goes for Thankbox, GroupGreeting, Givetastic and GroupLeavingCards.