Ideas
Group Card Alternatives: 5 Ways to Say It Together

Someone is leaving, retiring, turning fifty, having a baby or having a rough time, and a group of people want to say something together. The default is a group card or leaving card passed round the office. It's still a good option. It's not the only one. Here are five, with what each is good at and where each falls down.
1. The passed-round paper card
A large card in an envelope, carried desk to desk or left with someone discreet.
- Good: handwriting, cheap, familiar, and no technology involved. People like signing something real.
- Less good: only people in the building can sign it. Cards go missing in in-trays or get spotted by the person they're for. The last signers squeeze into the corners. And because people sign standing up, between meetings, most write "Good luck!" and little else.
Make it work: tape a list of names inside the envelope so people can tick themselves off, include a pen, set a return date, and ask two or three people to write proper messages first. Others follow their lead.
Suits: a small team in one place, at short notice.
2. A giant card from a shop
- Good: room for everyone, and it gets a laugh when it's handed over.
- Less good: awkward to pass round and to hide, and awkward to keep afterwards. Still in-person only.
Suits: a large office, a big birthday, or a team that likes a bit of theatre.
3. Online group cards and boards
There are websites where one person sets up a digital card or a shared board, sends a link, and everyone adds a message, often with a photo or an animated GIF. The person it's for gets a link to open. Services differ in what's free and what's paid, so check what's included before you start.
- Good: anyone, anywhere can sign. Quick to set up and quick to sign. Nothing to hide in a drawer. Usually more room for longer messages.
- Less good: it lives on a screen, and links get buried in inboxes. Some people love that it takes up no space; others want something they can hold.
Suits: remote and hybrid teams, last-minute occasions, and people who'd rather not have more things.
4. A group video
Each person records a short clip on their phone and one person edits them together. Some teams play it on the big screen at the leaving do.
- Good: faces and voices. Funny clips land better on video than on paper, and it works across any distance.
- Less good: plenty of people hate being on camera, so you get fewer contributors. Editing takes real time. And the quality varies wildly between the person in a quiet kitchen and the person filming on a train.
Make it work: ask for twenty to thirty seconds, filmed sideways, somewhere quiet. Give one prompt ("your favourite memory of working with her") and a firm deadline.
5. A printed group photo book
Each person gets a page: a photo and a few words, or a longer message on a page of its own. On Paper Chain, one person starts the book and shares one link. People add photos and a line about each from their phone, with no app or account, and the organiser checks the pages before ordering. Each photo prints on its own page with the caption underneath in large type, and a closing page lists everyone's names. It's printed near where it's going and posted.
- Good: everyone gets real space, remote people take part on equal terms, and it's a physical thing that lasts. Photos say a lot that a signature can't.
- Less good: it needs time for printing and delivery, so it isn't for tomorrow. It costs more than a card. The layout is fixed: one photo to a page, no handwriting. And someone has to organise it, though reminder emails do most of the chasing.
Suits: retirements, long-service leavers, big birthdays, a teacher from the class, anything where people have more to say than fits in a corner. See the leaving book for a colleague for how it works at work.
Side by side
| Paper card | Giant card | Online card or board | Group video | Group photo book | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Remote people can join | Only by post | Only by post | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Something to keep | Yes | Yes, if there's room | On screen | On screen | Yes |
| Lead time | A few days | A few days | Hours | A week or so | Allow for printing and delivery |
| Organiser's effort | Low | Low | Low | High (editing) | Medium |
| Room per person | A corner | More | Plenty | A short clip | A whole page |
Tips for any group card
- Set a deadline, a couple of days before you actually need it.
- Give a prompt. "Write one thing you'll miss" gets better messages than a blank space.
- Keep it secret. Don't discuss it in a channel the person can see.
- Think beyond the room. Former colleagues, people on leave, the night shift.
- Check the spelling of their name. Then check it on the envelope.
- Write the first message yourself, and make it a good one.
For wording, see leaving card messages, funny leaving card messages or what to write in a retirement card.
Which one?
- Short notice, everyone in one office: a paper card.
- Short notice, people everywhere: an online card or board.
- A team that's funny on camera and has someone who can edit: a video.
- A big moment, with time to plan: a printed book, perhaps with a paper card on the day as well.